Papers on tropical troposphere hotspot
Posted by Ari Jokimäki on September 6, 2009
This list contains papers on the tropical troposphere hotspot. The list is not complete, and will most likely be updated in the future in order to make it more thorough and more representative.
UPDATE (January 2, 2012): Fu et al. (2011) added.
UPDATE (September 21, 2010): McIntyre & McKitrick (2009) removed (it didn’t pass peer-review) and McKitrick et al. (2010) added.
UPDATE (January 4, 2009): Addendum for Douglass et al. (2008) added, thanks to kse for pointing this out, see the comment section below.
UPDATE (December 24, 2009): Fu et al. (2004) and Steiner et al. (2009) moved to global troposphere list. Some of the papers are still in both lists.
UPDATE (December 24, 2009): Sherwood et al. (2008) added and final publication links to Bengtsson & Hodges (2009) added.
UPDATE (September 23, 2009): Steiner et al. (2009) added, thanks for John Cook for pointing this out (see the comment section below). McCarthy et al. (2008) added.
UPDATE (September 13, 2009): Bengtsson & Hodges (2009?) added.
On the warming in the tropical upper troposphere: Models versus observations – Fu et al. (2011) “IPCC (Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change) AR4 (Fourth Assessment Report) GCMs (General Circulation Models) predict a tropical tropospheric warming that increases with height, reaches its maximum at ~200 hPa, and decreases to zero near the tropical tropopause. This study examines the GCM-predicted maximum warming in the tropical upper troposphere using satellite MSU (microwave sounding unit)-derived deep-layer temperatures in the tropical upper- and lower-middle troposphere for 1979–2010. While satellite MSU/AMSU observations generally support GCM results with tropical deep-layer tropospheric warming faster than surface, it is evident that the AR4 GCMs exaggerate the increase in static stability between tropical middle and upper troposphere during the last three decades.” Fu, Q., S. Manabe, and C. M. Johanson (2011), On the warming in the tropical upper troposphere: Models versus observations, Geophys. Res. Lett., 38, L15704, doi:10.1029/2011GL048101. [Full text]
Panel and multivariate methods for tests of trend equivalence in climate data series – McKitrick et al. (2010) “We explain panel and multivariate regressions for comparing trends in climate data sets. They impose minimal restrictions on the covariance matrix and can embed multiple linear comparisons, which is a convenience in applied work. We present applications comparing post-1979 modeled and observed temperature trends in the tropical lower- and mid-troposphere. Results are sensitive to the sample length. In data spanning 1979–1999, observed trends are not significantly different from zero or from model projections. In data spanning 1979–2009, the observed trends are significant in some cases but tend to differ significantly from modeled trends.” Ross McKitrick, Stephen McIntyre, Chad Herman, Atmospheric Science Letters, Article first published online: 17 SEP 2010, DOI: 10.1002/asl.290. [Full text]
On the evaluation of temperature trends in the tropical troposphere – Bengtsson & Hodges (2009) “A series of model experiments with the coupled Max-Planck-Institute ECHAM5/OM climate model have been investigated and compared with microwave measurements from the Microwave Sounding Unit (MSU) and re-analysis data for the period 1979-2008. … When forced by analysed sea surface temperature the model reproduces accurately the time-evolution of the mean outgoing tropospheric microwave radiation especially over tropical oceans but with a minor bias towards higher temperatures in the upper troposphere. … We have also compared the trend of the vertical lapse rate over the tropical oceans assuming that the difference between TLT and TMT is an approximate measure of the lapse rate. The TLT–TMT trend is larger in both the measurements and in the JRA25 than in the model runs by 0.04–0.06 K/decade. Furthermore, a calculation of all 30 year TLT–TMT trends of the unforced 500-year integration vary between ±0.03 K/decade suggesting that the models have a minor systematic warm bias in the upper troposphere.” [Full text]
Robust Tropospheric Warming Revealed by Iteratively Homogenized Radiosonde Data – Sherwood et al. (2008) “Results are presented from a new homogenization of data since 1959 from 527 radiosonde stations. … The troposphere warms at least as strongly as the surface, with local warming maxima at 300 hPa in the tropics” [Full text]
Toward Elimination of the Warm Bias in Historic Radiosonde Temperature Records—Some New Results from a Comprehensive Intercomparison of Upper-Air Data – Haimberger et al. (2008) “Both of the new adjusted radiosonde time series are in better agreement with satellite data than comparable published radiosonde datasets, not only for zonal means but also at most single stations. A robust warming maximum of 0.2–0.3K (10 yr)−1 for the 1979–2006 period in the tropical upper troposphere could be found in both homogenized radiosonde datasets.” [Full text]
Consistency of modelled and observed temperature trends in the tropical troposphere – Santer et al. (2008) “Early versions of satellite and radiosonde datasets suggested that the tropical surface had warmed more than the troposphere, while climate models consistently showed tropospheric amplification of surface warming in response to human-caused increases in well-mixed greenhouse gases (GHGs). We revisit such comparisons here using new observational estimates of surface and tropospheric temperature changes. We find that there is no longer a serious discrepancy between modelled and observed trends in tropical lapse rates. … Our results contradict a recent claim that all simulated temperature trends in the tropical troposphere and in tropical lapse rates are inconsistent with observations. This claim was based on use of older radiosonde and satellite datasets, and on two methodological errors: the neglect of observational trend uncertainties introduced by interannual climate variability, and application of an inappropriate statistical consistency test.” [Full text]
Warming maximum in the tropical upper troposphere deduced from thermal winds – Allen & Sherwood (2008) “Climate models and theoretical expectations have predicted that the upper troposphere should be warming faster than the surface. Surprisingly, direct temperature observations from radiosonde and satellite data have often not shown this expected trend. However, non-climatic biases have been found in such measurements. Here we apply the thermal-wind equation to wind measurements from radiosonde data, which seem to be more stable than the temperature data. … Warming patterns are consistent with model predictions except for small discrepancies close to the tropopause.” [Full text]
Assessing Bias and Uncertainty in the HadAT-Adjusted Radiosonde Climate Record – McCarthy et al. (2008) “This paper presents an automated homogenization method designed to replicate the decisions made by manual judgment in the generation of an earlier radiosonde dataset [i.e., the Hadley Centre radiosonde temperature dataset (HadAT)]. … Using climate model data to simulate biased radiosonde data, the authors show that limitations in the homogenization method are sufficiently large to explain much of the tropical trend discrepancy between HadAT and estimates from satellite platforms and climate models. … Previous assessment of trends and uncertainty in HadAT is likely to have underestimated the systematic bias in tropical mean temperature trends.” [Full text]
A comparison of tropical temperature trends with model predictions – Douglass et al. (2008) “We examine tropospheric temperature trends of 67 runs from 22 Climate of the 20th Century model simulations and try to reconcile them with the best available updated observations (in the tropics during the satellite era). Model results and observed temperature trends are in disagreement in most of the tropical troposphere, being separated by more than twice the uncertainty of the model mean.” [However, they ignored the observation uncertainties, see Santer et al. above and this RealClimate article.] [Full text] [Addendum]
Utility of Radiosonde Wind Data in Representing Climatological Variations of Tropospheric Temperature and Baroclinicity in the Western Tropical Pacific – Allen & Sherwood (2007) “Wind data show a slowing of the midlatitude jets in the Maritime Continent region since 1979, indicating that tropical thicknesses and temperature have increased less than those poleward of 25°N/S. This pattern is consistent with Microwave Sounding Unit temperature trends in the region but is exaggerated south of the equator in trends obtained directly from the temperature data. … These results support the use of the wind field as a way of overcoming heterogeneities in the temperature records in the monitoring of climate change patterns.” Allen, Robert J., Steven C. Sherwood, 2007, J. Climate, 20, 5229–5243. [Full text]
Tropical vertical temperature trends: A real discrepancy? – Thorne et al. (2007) “The uncertainty of inter-satellite calibration implied by available MSU T2 (mid-troposphere) estimates (σ = 0.035K) is much greater than that required to adequately resolve the trend (σ < 0.01K), or the amplification behaviour (implied amplification range ±0.95).”
Ozone, water vapor, and temperature in the upper tropical troposphere: Variations over a decade of MOZAIC measurements – Bortz et al. (2006) Provides another dataset for the tropics (by in situ aircraft samples), including water vapor and ozone measurements. “The decade of MOZAIC in situ measurements now available provides unique insights into the composition and processes of the upper tropical troposphere. In this analysis of temperature, water vapor, and ozone at flight cruise levels in the tropics, we find greater seasonal variability for all three parameters in the South (0–20°S) than in the North (0–20°N) Tropics.” [Full text]
The Vertical Structure of Temperature in the Tropics: Different Flavors of El Niño – Trenberth & Smith (2006) Discusses the strong role of El Niño on tropical temperatures. [Full text]
Temperature Trends in the Lower Atmosphere: Steps for Understanding and Reconciling Differences – Karl et al. (2006) Report about temperature trends in stratosphere and in troposphere. [Full text of chapter 1]
Satellite-derived vertical dependence of tropical tropospheric temperature trends – Fu & Johanson (2005) “For the tropical troposphere’s response to greenhouse forcing, GCMs predict a positive temperature trend that is greater than that at the surface and increases with height [e.g., Hansen et al., 2002]. … Tropical atmospheric temperatures in different tropospheric layers are retrieved using satellite-borne Microwave Sounding Unit (MSU) observations. We find that tropospheric temperature trends in the tropics are greater than the surface warming and increase with height. Our analysis indicates that the near-zero trend from Spencer and Christy’s MSU channel-2 angular scanning retrieval for the tropical low-middle troposphere (T2LT) is inconsistent with tropical tropospheric warming derived from their MSU T2 and T4 data.” [Full text]
Amplification of Surface Temperature Trends and Variability in the Tropical Atmosphere – Santer et al. (2005) Highlights the problematics of the issue, and also notes the role of El Niño in tropical temperature variability. “On multidecadal time scales, tropospheric amplification of surface warming is a robust feature of model simulations, but it occurs in only one observational data set. Other observations show weak, or even negative, amplification.” [Full text]
The Radiative Signature of Upper Tropospheric Moistening – Soden et al. (2005) “Climate models predict that the concentration of water vapor in the upper troposphere could double by the end of the century as a result of increases in greenhouse gases. Such moistening plays a key role in amplifying the rate at which the climate warms in response to anthropogenic activities, but has been difficult to detect because of deficiencies in conventional observing systems. We use satellite measurements to highlight a distinct radiative signature of upper tropospheric moistening over the period 1982 to 2004. The observed moistening is accurately captured by climate model simulations and lends further credence to model projections of future global warming.” [Full text]
There are a lot of papers discussing troposphere temperature trends from the global perspective. Those papers are not on the list above, but have their own list: